Island Cafe Menu
DinerIsland Cafe offers a relaxed coastal dining experience that reflects the charm of Everglades City, featuring a menu built around fresh seafood, classic American favorites, and satisfying comfort food. The selection includes hearty breakfast choices, flavorful lunch and dinner options, refreshing beverages, and casual meals suited for both locals and visitors exploring the area. Signature offerings often highlight the region’s seafood, with dishes prepared to showcase fresh ingredients, simple cooking techniques, and balanced flavors. The menu provides good value with generous portions, quality ingredients, and approachable pricing for everyday dining. Fresh seafood, crisp vegetables, and carefully prepared recipes create a satisfying combination of taste and texture. Options suitable for different preferences, including lighter meals, family-friendly selections, and customizable choices, make the menu welcoming for a variety of guests. Island Cafe is a great choice for a relaxed breakfast, a casual lunch stop, a comfortable dinner, or group meals with friends and family.
Menu Highlights
Seafood Platters
Featuring fresh local seafood prepared with classic coastal flavors, these platters offer a satisfying mix of tender seafood, crisp sides, and generous portions that make them a popular choice.
Shrimp Dishes
Prepared with quality shrimp and flavorful seasonings, these selections deliver a delicious balance of sweetness, freshness, and savory coastal character.
Fish Specialties
Fresh fish cooked with simple techniques allows the natural flavor and delicate texture of the seafood to stand out.
Breakfast Favorites
Classic breakfast plates provide comforting flavors with hearty portions, making them ideal for starting the day with a satisfying meal.
Burgers and Sandwiches
Juicy fillings, fresh toppings, and well-balanced flavors make these casual favorites a reliable choice for a quick and enjoyable meal.
Homestyle Specials
Daily-style offerings bring comforting recipes and familiar flavors, showcasing the cafe’s welcoming approach to traditional dining.
Top Menu Categories
Appetizers
-
Chicken Wings
$9.99 -
Cheese Sticks
$7.99 -
Fried Calamari
$8.99 -
Onion Rings
$7.99 -
Fried Mushrooms
$7.99 -
Fried Frog Legs
$10.99 -
Gator Nuggets
$11.99 -
Fried Oysters
$11.99 -
Fried Pickle Chips
$7.99 -
Hush Puppies (5)
$7.99 -
Cheese Curds
$7.99 -
Mac And Cheese Squares
$7.99
Salads
-
Chef's Salad
Turkey, ham, cheese, hardboiled egg, tomato, black olive
$11.99 -
Carolina Chicken Salad
Fried chicken tenders, hardboiled egg, tomato, cheese, served with honey mustard dressing
$11.99 -
Caesar Salad
$8.99 -
House Salad
$5.99
Soups
-
New England Clam Chowder
$ -
Chili
$ -
Our Soup Of The Day
$
Sandwiches
-
Fish
(Blackened, broiled, or fried)
$11.99 -
Shrimp Po'boy
$13.99 -
Oyster Po’boy
$14.99 -
Chicken Bacon Melt
$9.99 -
Bbq Pork On Garlic Toast
$9.99 -
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
$9.99 -
Steak Sandwich
$11.99 -
Hamburger
$7.99 -
Cheeseburger
$8.99 -
Pizza Burger
(Mozzeralla cheese & pizza sauce)
$8.99 -
Buffalo Chicken Bacon Melt
$10.99 -
Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato
$8.99 -
Soft Shell Blue Crab
$13.99 -
Grilled Shrimp Burger
$13.99 -
Tuna Salad
$8.99
Tacos
-
Fish Tacos
$11.99 -
Gator Tacos
$14.99 -
Shrimp Tacos
$13.99 -
Bbq Pork Tacos
Served with cole slaw on top
$11.99
Wraps
-
Fried Gator
$14.99 -
Buffalo Shrimp
$13.99 -
Shrimp
$13.99 -
Chicken Caesar
$9.99 -
Fish
$10.99 -
Chicken Bacon Ranch
$9.99 -
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
$9.99 -
Seafood Combo
(Shrimp, scallop, fish)
$16.99
Baskets
-
Clam Strips
$9.99 -
Fried Oysters
$14.99 -
Crab Cakes
$13.99 -
Gator
$14.99 -
Seafood Combo
(Fish, clam strips, oyster, shrimp and frog legs)
$17.99
Vegetarian Corner
-
Veggi Burger
$7.99 -
Veggi Wrap
$7.99
Cafe Specials
-
Hot Brown
Heated open face ham and turkey smothered in a cheese sauce and topped with tomato and bacon
$13.99 -
Gator Burger
Ground gator patty on a toasted bun
$14.99 -
Cheddar Chili Dogs
Served with french fries (2)
$10.99 -
Fish Reuben
Fish fillet served on rye bread, topped with cole slaw, sliced tomato and thousand island dressing
$12.99 -
Crab Cake Reuben
Crab cakes served on rye bread, topped with cole slaw, sliced tomato and thousand island dressing
$13.99 -
Quesadilla
$
Desserts
-
Key Lime Pie
$4.99 -
Fried Key Lime Pie
$5.99 -
Pecan Pie
$4.99 -
Fried Twinkie
$5.99 -
Peanut Butter Pie
$5.99
Beverages
-
Coffee
$2.50 -
Iced Tea
$3.00 -
Lemonade
$3.00 -
Soda
$3.00 -
Bottled Water
$2.50
Others
-
Pizza
Build your own 16-inch pizza
$ -
Full Liquor Bar, Beer And Wine
Ask your server
$ -
Ice Cream Shop
Check out our for a cool, creamy treat!
$ -
You Hook'em We Cook'em
We will cook them
$
Subscribe to Newsletter!
Subscribe to get latest updates and information.