Sebastian's Steak House

The food was good, the knives were dull and need to be replaced. Otherwise, it was a very nice restaurant like a supper club.

We visited Sebastian's a couple of days ago and my wife, sister-in-law and I had a couple of appetizers beforehand...specifically, Mozzarella Sticks ( which were QUITE large and also contained some kind of seasoning -- perhaps basil ) and Deep Fried Cheese Curds, both of which were excellent. Next I had the soup, which was Creamy Chicken and Rice...another plus. Finally for my main course I had an 8 oz ounce tenderloin fillet with garlic mashed potatoes. One word: EXCELLENT. The steak was prepared how I had asked and everything tasted amazing. Due to our appetizers and my soup, I had enough leftovers to have about half my steak, all of my potatoes and one mozzarella stick the next day for lunch. You really can't ask for anything better !

High quality food and always good service!  Be sure to go early (right at opening) to beat the crowd and avoid a possible wait.  I love their cheesy garlic bread they serve before your meal!  We usually end up devouring two loaves before meal time.  As a vegetarian, their menu is pretty limited for me, but to be expected at a steakhouse!  For a steakhouse, their fettuccini is always delicious and perfectly cooked.  And, be sure to go there on your birthday to enjoy a generously sized brownie sundae, on the house!  Atmosphere is always clean and inviting. It is higher priced so expect to pay.

Went here with some work friends after being recommended this place by locals. The atmosphere was a true Wisconsin supper club experience. The steaks were all fabulous, well cooked, and the price was very fair with each steak being under $30. I highly recommend this steakhouse.

Ordered 8 0z filet it was tasty and cooked well. Side order of mushrooms were cold. Onion rings just average. Service was slow but she was friendly. Our first visit and will try again.

Absolutely delicious. We arrived at 4 with no waiting. Everything was cooked perfect.

When leaving the young hostess never said goodbye just smiled. This was our first time there. It was my son's birthday. For what we spent there atleast acknowledge your customers when walking out and ask them how was everything? We drove an hour to Fondy. Cause my son wanted to go there. But overall great.

My plate look good but my food wasn't cooked properly The crab legs were overdone.. you couldn't get them out of the shelves.. And I'm an expert with crab let me tell you And a steak I've eaten steak there before but this was really small and that's fine but it wasn't tender and melting like it usually is it was just a little bit rough.