Mccarty Mercantile Menu

McCarty Mercantile in Hillsgrove combines the charm of a historic country mercantile with the comforting appeal of a neighborhood café. The menu centers on homestyle breakfast and lunch fare alongside a notable scratch-made pizza program, with pancakes, eggs, breakfast meats, sandwiches, pizza, stromboli, calzones, and breadsticks among the offerings. Coffee provides a classic accompaniment to breakfast and casual daytime meals. Recent menu information highlights pizzas such as spinach and tomato, Meat Lover’s, Supreme, White, and Margherita, while the Reuben Stromboli offers a creative house specialty. Pizza dough and sauces are made from scratch, with meats and vegetables sourced from local businesses, giving the food a fresh, carefully prepared character.

Typical spending is around $10-$20 per person, making the generous, freshly prepared fare appealing for its value. Vegetarian-friendly choices include spinach-and-tomato and Margherita-style pizzas, though diners needing strict gluten-free meals should confirm current options directly. Familiar breakfast dishes and customizable pizzas also make the menu approachable for children. Breakfast and lunch are natural fits, while pizza, stromboli, and the Mercantile’s Saturday dinner-and-music tradition make it equally inviting for relaxed dinners and group gatherings.

Menu Highlights

Spinach & Tomato Pizza
A popular combination with fresh vegetable flavor, melted cheese, and a crisp-chewy scratch-made crust. Its simple balance makes it an appealing meat-free choice.

White Pizza
Ricotta and garlic oil create a rich, creamy, aromatic pizza without traditional red sauce. It stands out for its savory simplicity and smooth texture.

Reuben Stromboli
A distinctive house creation inspired by the familiar Reuben sandwich, wrapped inside freshly prepared dough. It is a particularly memorable choice for diners seeking something beyond standard pizza.

Meat Lover’s Pizza
A hearty option combining the Mercantile’s scratch-made pizza base with a meat-forward topping selection. It suits diners looking for a filling lunch or casual dinner.

Supreme Pizza
A loaded combination of toppings brings contrasting savory flavors and textures to the house-made crust. It is especially well suited to sharing with family or friends.

Pancakes
Soft, comforting pancakes are one of the café’s noted breakfast favorites. Their classic griddled character pairs naturally with coffee for an easygoing morning meal.