Shakespeare's Steak And Seafood

Five stars, every single time. Shakespeare’s in Hamilton is a true local institution — decades strong, family-run across multiple generations, and still anchored by Franco in the kitchen, quietly grilling up pure magic. The food is the heart of the place, and it shows. The steaks are, quite simply, phenomenal: perfectly seasoned, flawlessly cooked, and consistently among the best you’ll find anywhere in the region. Every dish feels classic in the best possible way — generous, well-executed, and deeply satisfying. Service is impeccable, polished without being stuffy, and the whole experience has that timeless, old-school fine-dining charm that’s getting harder and harder to find. I’ve been coming here for decades — first with my family, and now with my own — and the quality has never wavered. In a city where dining trends come and go, Shakespeare’s stands on its own. There is no other fine-dining restaurant in Hamilton with this level of staying power, consistency, and culinary excellence. A rock-solid 5 out of 5 stars.

I live very close to this restaurant so I was happy to finally try it. A large group of us celebrated my best friend's birthday. It was nice to get the back story on the establishment from our server Cory. Owned and operated by the Chef who hasn't missed a day of work in over 55 years!! He even came to the table to say hi and sing Happy birthday to the birthday girl! The food was good and everyone seemed to enjoy our evening there. They bring out garlic bread for the table and also olives feta cheese and some tasty pickles. Right now they have a 3 course fixed menu available. U hope to come back soon to try something else off the menu. It's a fine dining establishment so it's a bit pricey but in my eyes worth it.

We had a wonderful experience at Shakespeare’s last weekend. This family-owned restaurant truly embodies the essence of traditional fine dining—offering warm hospitality, an elegant and inviting atmosphere, impeccable service, and, of course, exceptional food.

That was unbelievably good experience! I loved everything from the very first moment I opened the door of this restaurant. The absolutely sweet lady picked up our coat and then we entered the restaurant. The waiters were all friendly, moderately talkative, and witty. They easily adjusted to our communication style and created friendly and welcoming atmosphere. As soon as we sit at the table we were immediately served with water and some complimentary snacks and were provided with menus. The waiters are knowledgeable about the menu and can really present and sell it without pressure and in enjoyable ways. The food itself was good. I definitely want to try some other options they have next time. The atmosphere was great! Not too loud music, so we could talk easily. Other guests far enough so we don’t interfere each others. Even though the place closed at 10 pm, no one was rushing us to leave and let us stay and enjoy our meal and wait for the car till almost 11 pm. Absolutely great experience. And I even say so far the best in my almost 3 years in Canada. Thank you all and best wishes to your business!

I love this restaurant the food is amazing and service is exceptional! The whole experience makes you feel like you’ve taken a mini trip to Italy.

2024.04 My friend and I had dinner here to celebrate our birthdays, and really had a wonderful night. Everyone was super friendly especially Warner, who is so kind and professional. We ordered one 12oz ribeye to share and it was served in two dishes beautifully. We got the dessert with sparkle for our birthdays and the apply pie was so good! It was very nice of them to sing happy birthday for us. As a matter of fact, there were also other three groups of guests celebrating birthdays the same night and we got to hear the birthday song four times! Many thanks! Food was good, despite being a little bit too salty for us. It was amazing to experience the cooking by the original owner/chef since the store was opened in 1969, and to see the original deco and the retro paper order form! Overall, I would highly recommend this restaurant!

Had the most amazing dinner here! You can order anything off the menu but they also have a long list of specials. The food was delicious and the service was even better. We celebrated a friend's birthday and I don't think we could have had a better time. The complimentary birthday desert that most restaurants give to the birthday guest, they gave to each of us. Such a nice touch. We are already looking forward to coming back and bringing more people to enjoy the experience.

If you're looking for a truly memorable dining experience, look no further than Shakespeare Restaurant. From the moment you step through the door, you're transported into a world of old-world charm and timeless elegance. The cozy, atmospheric setting—reminiscent of a bygone era—sets the perfect stage for what’s to come. The food is nothing short of outstanding. Each dish is expertly prepared, bursting with flavour, and beautifully presented. Whether you're indulging in a classic or exploring one of their signature creations, every bite reflects a deep passion for culinary excellence. What truly sets Shakespeare Restaurant apart, though, is the exceptional service. The staff are warm, attentive, and genuinely committed to ensuring every guest feels welcomed and cared for. Our waiter Ben was witty, fun & knowledgable and even the cook came out to greet our party too. It's that rare kind of service that turns a great meal into an unforgettable experience. It’s no surprise that Shakespeare Restaurant wins the Consumer Choice Award every year—a well-deserved recognition for a place that consistently delivers on quality, service, and ambiance. Whether it's a special occasion or simply a night out, Shakespeare Restaurant offers a dining experience that’s both refined and inviting. Highly recommended!