Description
38 Dairy is a restaurant situated at 2625 Broad St, New Castle, IN 47362, United States, with a total of 94 user reviews. Known for a variety of featured dishes such as the Banana Split, Coney Dog, M&M Flurry, Sundaes, and the Regular Tenderloin Sandwich, it offers diverse menu options. The restaurant's peak hours feature waits that can extend up to 45 minutes Monday, Friday, Saturday, and Sunday afternoons generally from 3:00 PM to around 5:30 PM, with shorter waits of up to 15 minutes on Tuesdays and Wednesdays from 2:00 PM to 6:00 PM, and about 30-minute waits on Thursdays. This schedule indicates the busiest periods for those popular items, making afternoon visits a lively time to enjoy this local eatery.
Amenities
- Outdoor seating
- Takeout
- Dine-in
- Delivery
- Great dessert
- Serves local specialty
- Solo dining
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
- Wheelchair accessible seating
- Comfort food
- Dessert
- Table service
- Restroom
- Accepts reservations
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- Good for kids
- Kids' menu
- Free parking lot
- Free street parking
- Parking
Reviews (94)
Add Your Review
Nearby Places to Eat & Drink
Subscribe to Newsletter!
Suggest Edit
First ime being here and im impressed i got a banana shake and then my fiance got a chocolate peanut butter shake and they were so good. The guy was very polite he brought us a menu while we were sitting in our truck. (Most people wouldnt do that) the shakes had real friute in them vs. Syrup and these bad boys were thick. The way these shakes were made is like you whipped em up at home very comforting. The price for 2 large shake wasnt that bad either over all very satisfied
Brent was cool. He's in his sixties and spry as ever. I basically got served a side salad on top of my burger. More bacon than I've ever seen on a burger too. He sources his products locally, is what I heard from him! It was delicious. Call ahead and make your order quicker!
Place was great! The guy working was super nice and we got our food pretty quick, and I dont know if it’s homemade but feels like it. It taste good and fresh! Update, went there again and everything is homemade and they add stuff to the menu all the time! This place is great for a quick, cheap, good bite to eat!
Good to have them open again. Had my first tenderloin and French Fries of the year! Would have gotten tge amazing onion rings but deferring to another day. They were delicious. Have leftovers for another year. Take care of yourself.
Coney dog and fries! Great service and good food. Thank you!
This was an awesome experience. The owner has a great work ethic and attention to detail on all levels of the product being served. The owner told us how he hand selects the ingredients to ensure quality, as opposed to buying in bulk. $8 for a few local fresh tomatoes means 50 cents a slice, but he does what needs to be done to make sure people come back. And believe me, you will! Every ingredient was super flavorful and it’s no wonder why. The mushroom swiss burger was the best I’ve ever had in my whole 40 years of life. Great texture, flavor, and applied thick as the meat patty itself. The onion rings crunched so crispily as it probably could be heard a mile away. Not greasy, just flavor and texture. I wish I was local; I’d sample everything on the menu, and probably multiple times! I was blown away by this inconspicuous establishment! Great small business and humble owner! Love it!
This place is great. The onion rings (which were actually straws) were to die for. And the shake was thiiiiick. Will definitely be back!
Been coming here since 2016 some of the best food and ice cream in the area. I highly recommend anyone to come checkout this place. No one does it like Brent does