American Seasons

We LOVE everything about Seasons...food is excellent, meticulously prepared, visually appealing and tantalizing to the taste buds. We ate here two nights in a row on our Na tucket visit just to enjoy most of the menu before leaving the island. Love the patio and the quaint seating by the window. Staff was so friendly and attentive. Fave dishes: whipped ricotta, gazpacho, risotto, buratta, roast scallops, beef strip loin with braised beef cheek, halibut, giannone chicken and the sticky pudding for dessert is outstanding! Servings are quite plentiful.

Great cocktails and great food! I highly recommend. Pricey and the portions are small but the food and presentation were very good. I had the seasonal Rhubarb Cocktail and the Arctic Char

Cozy, warm, rustic Nantucket, off the tourist beat but well known locally with super friendly staff and outstanding American cuisine. The prices are fair for the area and for the food and service quality. I had the pork shoulder which was nicely sized, expertly prepared, and flavorful but not overwhelmingly spiced (as some restaurants do). My wife had the scallops with an amazing sauce that perfectly complimented the scallops. Be aware though that they are still slammed by lack of staff so be prepared to relax and enjoy a calm and paced evening. Big call out to Bridget your server who kept her calm and friendly manner about her even though clearly stressed, as she also had to fill in for the host who was missing this evening. Minus one star, though, for the management who was completely missing in action, and who could have come around to greet and apologize for the delays (we and others had to wait about 30 minutes past our reservation time to get seated, and one couple was even threatened with a $50/person service charge for cancellation when they inquired earlier in the evening!). However, these being extraordinary times as the season on Nantucket is just wrapping up, we will certainly give them another try next season!

This is hands down our favorite restaurant on the island. Food is spectacular. They need to get some of the service kinks out. But lately, one of the owners has been on hand to quickly rectify any issues- which goes a long way. Thank you, Cheryl! We will always be back.

Other than it taking forever for them to seat us everything was fantastic. The food was so good! And the atmosphere was great! I would highly recommend American Seasons!

We had a large party so it took a while to prepare our table, but we were able to squeeze into the tiny bar area for a drink while waited. The wait was worth it as the appetizers and entrees were delicious. Would recommend.

I liked the restaurant, it was my first time there, I had good impressions. Great dishes, beautiful atmosphere, polite staff

Delicious meal, based on fresh ingredients especially great seafood, fun cocktails (as fans of Depeche Mode we particularly like The Pêche Mode!), and excellent service. Yes, it's pricey, but this is Nantucket and American Seasons is a worthy landmark on the island. Highly recommended.